Should I Tell a Pisces Man How I Feel?

Written by Angel Eyedealism | Edited by Caroline Heiderscheit

Last Updated: April 15, 2025 Fact Checked

When you form a crush, sharing your true feelings can be nerve-wracking. When it's a Pisces man you're crushing on though, you have nothing to fear—these tenderhearted water signs will definitely be gentle and understanding. Below, we'll walk you through the entire process. Should you tell him how you feel? If so, how? And how can you figure out how he's feeling about you? We'll answer all your burning questions and more. Read on to learn how you can share your true feelings with a Pisces man!

This article is based on an interview with our astrologer and performance artist, Angel Eyedealism. Check out the full interview here.

Section 1 of 3:

Should you share your feelings?

Download Article

Yes, you deserve to share your feelings—and a Pisces will be empathetic. When you develop feelings for someone, telling your crush can be scary. But love always takes a little risk, and you may end up being rewarded for your bravery. Get your Pisces alone, share your message, and be honest with him.
- Maybe he'll feel the same. Then suddenly, you're getting romantic with a dreamy, kind, super sweet Pisces.

Section 2 of 3:

How to Share Your Feelings With a Pisces Man

Download Article

1
"I want to be honest with you—I like you." Be straightforward, open, and authentic when sharing feelings with Pisces. Ruled by Neptune, Pisces is empathetic—so he won't freak out if you share your genuine emotions.^{[1]
X
Research source} Instead of being coy or playing it cool, let your true feelings fly. Whether or not he reciprocates, he’ll appreciate that you were in touch and upfront with your own emotions.
- Describe how he makes you feel: “I always feel my best when I’m around you.”
- Tell him what you appreciate about him: “You’re such a caring person, and I really admire that.”
- And explain the level of your feelings: “This is really big for me. I don’t usually form crushes like this, but I’m really into you.”
2
"I like you exactly as you are." Pisces men are terrified of feeling limited or controlled in love. So, make it clear that you don’t plan to do either of those things—instead, you just want to appreciate him for who he is. Explain that you’ll accept his feelings and if he is interested in you, you’re committed to accepting him for him.
- “I just want to say that no matter what, I’ll accept how you feel. I may need time, but I won’t be mad if you don’t feel the same way I do.”
- "I'm not into the person you could be. I like you for exactly who you are right now."
- “To me, you're perfect. I wouldn’t dream of trying to change you.”
3
"I want to be the person who's there for you when you're feeling down." In love, Pisces is looking for someone to help him process his ever-changing, intense emotions. When you tell him how you feel, explain that you’d like to be his rock and confidant. Tell him that because you care about him, you’d like to care for him—and that means supporting him emotionally.
- “I really want to make you feel cared for.”
- “I just want to make you happy."
- "I know you go through a lot. I want to help you process all of your big emotions."
4
"I do really like you, but I would never want you to feel uncomfortable." Be gentle with Pisces, because these men are extremely sensitive.^{[2]
X
Expert Source

Angel Eyedealism
Astrologer & Performance Artist

Expert Interview} When you explain how you feel, he’ll be a great listener—unless you unintentionally make him feel attacked or confronted. Speak softly, remind him that your feelings are your own (and he’s not responsible for them!), and at all costs, avoid hurting his feelings.
- Sometimes, when we care a lot about someone, it can actually make us resent them, especially if we feel a little led on.
- When sharing your feelings with a Pisces man, keep these feelings in check. Say, “You made me fall for you. This is your fault!” and he’ll shut down.
- Instead, remind him that because you care about him, you’ve got great intentions: “I like you, but I don’t blame you or expect anything in return.”
5
"Do you feel the same?" Ask your Pisces if the crush goes both ways. If he says yes, then that's amazing news! Your bravery paid off, and you should definitely ask him on a date (bonus points for something creative, like a poetry reading!). If he doesn't feel the same, don't stress. Pisces will be super respectful about your feelings. Take a deep breath and explain that you'll need time to think.
- First, ask him how he feels: "Now you know that I'm into you. But are you into me, too?"
- Then, if he's interested, ask him out: "Wow, amazing. I'd love to keep getting to know you. Would you want to come to this art gallery opening with me?"
- If he's not, you'll need to take some time to decide how you want to proceed. Explain this to him: "Okay, thanks for your honesty. I need to do some reflection before I reach back out."
6
"For us to move forward, I think I need to set boundaries with you." Depending on how your conversation goes, you may want to stay friends, become partners, or take some time away. It’s possible that with this free-spirited water sign, you’ll need to protect your own needs, because Pisces men may struggle to set and follow rules. Reflect on what you want, communicate that to him, and then enforce your boundaries.
- “Hey, I’m so glad I shared my feelings with you, but now I need to take some time away to regroup.”
- “I’ll need you to respect that. So please, don’t call or text me at all this week. I’ll reach out when I’m ready.”
- If necessary, enforce the boundaries you’ve set: “I asked you not to reach out, remember? I really need you to listen.”
Joanna Martine Woolfolk, Astrologer

When sharing feelings with a Pisces man, be open and gentle. Pisces are deeply empathetic, so honest, heartfelt emotion will resonate most. Express yourself sincerely — he'll feel the authenticity. Remember, Pisces cherish emotional bonds. Creating a safe space for vulnerability can bring you closer. Approach sensitively and emphasize your connection.

Section 3 of 3:

Signs That a Pisces Man Has Feelings for You

Download Article

1
He’s shy around you. As a mutable sign, Pisces men can be a bit reserved—especially around their crush. If a Pisces guy has his eye on you, he may totally clam up in your presence. Look out for signs that he’s nervous around you. If he goes quiet the second you walk into the room, know that that could be a sign he’s into you.
- He may also fidget while you two are in conversation.
- If he's got a crush, he may ask everyone in the room a question besides you.
- Even though you’ve seen him be super friendly and outgoing to others in the past, you may notice that with you, the Pisces man seems shy and closed off.
2
He’s affectionate with you. When a Pisces gets more comfortable with you (like when you’ve become friends or started flirting), he’s likely to warm up, and warm up quickly. He may suddenly save all of his sweetest compliments and hugs for you. Look for signs that he treats you with a little more warmth than he does the average person. This could definitely mean that he likes you!
- He might hold intense, long eye contact with you in conversation.
- A Pisces man might find every reason to compliment you, especially in front of other people.
- He may offer you sweet forms of physical affection, like hugs, an arm around the shoulder, or a pat on the knee.
3
He talks about his passions and dreams. To Pisces men, fantasy and intense emotion are some of the most exciting parts of life.^{[3]
X
Research source} So if he’s into you, he’ll want to share those experiences with you. If you notice him talking your ear off about his love of songwriting or his plan to become an architect, take note. This could absolutely be a sign that this Pisces man is falling for you.^{[4]
X
Research source}
- He might want to keep you updated on every detail of his favorite creative project.
- A Pisces man may enthusiastically describe his dreams to you (or even show you his dream journal!).
- He may pepper you with questions about your dreams and passions as well. So if you want to impress him, have your answers ready to go!
4
He wants to be there for you. A Pisces man will care deeply about supporting the people around him however he can, and with his crush, this will be extra important.^{[5]
X
Expert Source

Angel Eyedealism
Astrologer & Performance Artist

Expert Interview} If it seems like he’s always the one coming to your rescue, take note. Whether he’s your empathetic ear, your shoulder to cry on, or your knight in shining armor, if a Pisces man puts you first, that's a sign that he likes you.^{[6]
X
Expert Source

Stina Garbis
Psychic Astrologer

Expert Interview}
- He may be quick to offer a tub of ice cream and a box of tissues when you say you’ve had a bad day.
- A Pisces man may want to help you talk through things you’ve been through. He may ask tons of questions and offer his compassion when you mention past struggles.
- If you left something important at home, he might immediately offer to run back and grab it for you.
5
He wants to know everything about you. Pisces men want to make other people feel heard and understood.^{[7]
X
Expert Source

Angel Eyedealism
Astrologer & Performance Artist

Expert Interview} If he’s into you, this instinct in him will be even stronger. If you feel like he locks you into intense, personal conversation at every party, take note. Look out for signs that he’s trying really hard to get to know you, and pro tip: to impress him, let him! Pisces men love an open book.
- He may ask you about your childhood, your future plans, or your deepest fears.
- When you mention a casual personal detail, a Pisces man may immediately ask you for more information.

Join the Discussion...

Anyone have experience dating a Pisces man?

WikiElephantReader409

Had my first date with a Pisces guy a few days ago and I think we really hit it off but I've never dated a Pisces before and would love any tips/advice/insight about what it's like. Can you tell me what to expect or watch out for?

WikiLorisRider448

I was married to Pisces for over 10 years until his passing (I'm a Capricorn). He was a big, buff biker, but all teddy bear once he let the tough exterior drop. Yes, very romantic! He would rather walk through a side lot of field and pick flowers for me than buy them! He enjoyed when I would praise him for his nature, or tell him exactly what I loved about him. But be sincere! Flattering him without honesty will pay him away; he will distrust you more. Do begin early by telling him one or two private things nobody else knows about you. If it's serious, he will feel like you're confidante and will open up quicker. But always maintain respect and loyalty, with honesty- sometimes the hard truth he'll appreciate more than if you sugarcoat it, as long as you use the correct soft tone of voice, and assure him that the truth is to help him, not harm him. My guy LOVED any little thing that showed I was thinking about him- a heart drawn on his napkin in his lunch bag, a few candies on his pillow if I went to bed early, smiley faces drawn on pancakes with chocolate chips, too! Home cooking and a real sense of maintaining our home really got kudos from him!
If you are intimate, be prepared to have your head completely blown off! But don't expect him to jump right in the sack with you. My guy had to be 100% that I was completely into him and totally loyal. Oh, yeah! This guy! He was my soulmate, my perfect match. We laughed all the time, danced to our music ('80's) in the grocery store aisles, sang at the top of our lungs when driving around. Our connection and commitment was palpable, and we were always being complimented on being such a far out couple!
My Pisces man was everything I dreamed of since I was a little girl- my Knight in shining armour who protected me and kept me safe, who played on his knees before bedtime, and rode a Harley and was completely covered in tattoos!!!
He WAS real. And although I was only gifted him from God for ten years, we lived reach day to the absolute maximum, always with each other, holding hands or my arm in his. He lived to kiss me, and just all his devotion made me want to do anything in the world just to see his smile and hear his laughter.
I can't think of a negative, except maybe don't be a nagger or try to win an argument based on emotional manipulation. My husband would walk out of the house. I knew he would come back, and would be loyal, but I would never know for how long he would be gone. And with him being in an MC, I always got a bit concerned. But Pisces are very trustworthy and honourable. He never needed a reason to keep a secret, and I knew everything about him. But he did have just one, and kept it for almost 3 1/2 years until after our 2nd anniversary ----- he had won a personal non-taxable, non-wage settlement with 9 zeros behind it and didn't know what to do with it!
We'd been living within our means, and he trusted me to find a good investment broker. We had an additional monthly draw from a percentage of the interest earned, and that was it. It allowed us to buy a more reliable vehicle, and go to the movies on the weekend. But grandkids started popping out, and Christmases were really a lot of fun!
You will never go wrong with a Pisces man, as long as you maintain your integrity and are always honest with him, show him how much you appreciate him, and remember how much he like to feel your hand touching him or lips kissing him. I miss my husband so terribly. I truly lost a huge piece of my heart and soul.

Learn How to Attract a Pisces Man with this Expert Series

Pisces men are brilliant and romantic dreamers, though they can often be shy. We've put together this expert series to help you understand Pisces and attract the Pisces man of your dreams.